Escondido, CA

Elfin Forest/Harmony Grove sue Board of Supervisors over allowing development

JP Theberge, chairman of the Elfin Forest Harmony Grove Town Council, speaking at Tuesday’s press conference announcing the council’s lawsuit against the Board of Supervisors.

Citing the risks of wildfire and limited evacuation routes, The Town Council of Elfin Forest Harmony Grove has announced it is suing the San Diego County Board of Supervisors for amending the General Plan to approve more housing developments with what the council calls, “unsafe evacuation plans.”

The lawsuit cites two recently approved amendments to the General Plan, the proposed Harmony Grove Village South and Valiano developments. 

According to the lawsuit, “The proposed Harmony Grove Village South development has a staged evacuation plan for fire emergencies, which is the same type of plan that was used in the recent Paradise fire. These developments would also significantly increase housing densities in a non-urban area.”

According to the plaintiffs, “There have been 19 wildfires since 1980 within three miles of the Elfin Forest Harmony Grove valley, with numerous houses lost and at least one death. The County has approved a proposal to allow an additional 800 homes in this area, with the use of staged evacuations on the two-lane road needed for evacuation.”

In a press release on Tuesday, the group declared, “The recent fires in Paradise and Malibu are a clear warning sign that we need to rethink the way we build homes in the wildland-urban interface. The housing development proposed for Harmony Grove Village South puts residents directly in harm’s way. Just like the situation in Paradise, there are very limited routes out, so fast evacuations in a fire emergency are not a realistic plan.”

The press released concluded, “The people of San Diego want safe, well-planned, affordable housing. The Harmony Grove Village South and Valiano proposals are the opposite of those things. We urge the Board of Supervisors to prioritize public health and safety over developer profits. We could avoid a future tragedy on the magnitude of what happened in Paradise, by making better decisions today.”

One response to “Elfin Forest/Harmony Grove sue Board of Supervisors over allowing development”

  1. Jim Evans says:

    It’s not just the emergency situation that will be a problem, it’s the every day traffic problem these new developments will cause. These new residents will have to shop and get to work. There are few ways to get in and out. Harmony Grove Rd and Country Club Drive are narrow 2 lane rural roads that are not designed to be throughfares. They have already become commuter short cut routes to avoid using Hwy 78. Only one road, Harmony Grove Parkway, can handle additional traffic and that is getting busier each day as more homes in Harmony Grove Village are finished and occupied. This Parkway terminates at Citracado Parkway where Escondido has dropped the ball in building the bridge across Escondido Creek. Consequently, more and more traffic is short cutting through the Escondido neighborhoods using S Hale Ave and Avenida Del Diablo. I know all this from 1st hand experience as I live (and ride my bike daily) on these roads.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *