Escondido, CA

Conservation group urges Brown to change approach to fighting wildfires

The Escondido-based California Chaparral Institute has called on Governor Jerry Brown to adopt a wildfire strategy that concentrates as much on the wide open spaces as it does forests.
The institute, which describes its mission as a “nonprofit educational and research organization dedicated to the preservation of the chaparral, California’s most extensive ecosystem, and supporting the creative spirit as inspired by nature,” last week sent 12 recommendations to the governor under the heading: “A Plea to Governor Brown – Protect us from the wildfires that threaten us most. It’s not about forests. Twelve Recommendations to protect communities from wildfire based on science and the needs of our families at greatest risk.”
The recommendation was made in reaction to the governor’s Executive Order of May 10, 2018 is to “Protect Communities from Wildfire.” The order emphasizes that “eight of the state’s 20 most destructive fires have occurred in the past four years.”
The Chaparral Institute communication responds: “Unfortunately, the Order’s key elements will do little to protect communities at the greatest risk of destruction because the focus is on the wrong place – forests. The most devastating wildfires cited (including the Thomas, Tubbs, Nuns, and Atlas Fires) were many miles away from such forests. And while it is reasonable to remove hazard trees immediately adjacent to roads and homes, it makes no sense to spend millions of dollars to treat entire forests while the actual fire threat facing thousands of families occurs very far away from these forests.”
It continues, “We must address the conditions that are actually causing so many lost lives and homes – wind-driven wildfires and the embers they produce that ignite flammable structures placed in harm’s way by local planning entities. Failure to do so will only result in continued losses.”
The letter adds, “The current approach sees nature only as ‘fuel. Eliminate the ‘fuel,’ the thinking goes, and we can control the fires. Consequently, millions of dollars are spent clearing habitat and removing dead trees which frequently lead to creation of more flammable landscapes. As evidenced by the 2017 wildfires, the wildland fuel approach is failing us. The current approach is equivalent to trying to prevent earthquakes.”
The non-profit notes that it has worked with fire scientists and land managers, to assemble “. . .twelve recommendations based on decades of research to help us learn to live with wildfire instead of thinking we can control nature. We must look at the problem from the house outward, rather than from the wildland in. It’s our neighborhoods that are burning, so we must first make existing communities fire safe through retrofits, then ensure future developments are not built in fire corridors like those destroyed in Santa Rosa and Ventura during the 2017 wildfires.”
The California Chaparral Institute’s letter to Governor Brown with recommendations is available here (hard copies available upon request):

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *